aka First Rib Syndrome
(Keywords: THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME, inter scalene triangle, tingling in arms and hands, arm pain)
The "inter scalene triangle"
The inter, between, scalene triangle is an easy to visualise two dimensional structure bounded by the anterior and medial scalene muscles and the first rib below. Through this narrow passage both the brachial plexus and subclavian artery pass on their way from the chest to the arm. Thus compromise of this space can cause both neurological and or vascular signs and symptoms giving a complex and often confusing pattern of shoulder and arm pain, paresthesias in any part of the arm and radiating potentially in a non dermatomal pattern to all fingers.
The arm tires easily, especially with overhead use, and may feel cold and become pale. Many of the shoulder and arm conditions treated in chiropractic clinics have a chronic thoracic outlet syndromes as their underlying cause. For example, frozen shoulders, tennis elbow ...
The scalene muscles
The anterior and medial scalene muscles that bound the inter scalene triangle, we will ignore the posterior scalene, have the transverse proceses of the c2-c7 as their origin, and insert onto the first rib.
They are an accessory to breathing, raising the first rib, and also laterally flex the neck to the same side.
They are innervated by c3-c6.
The triangle may be palpated by rotating and laterally flexing the head and neck to the opposite side, and gently running the fingers posterior to the sterno cleido mastoid muscle, following the scalenes caudally as they descend deep behind the clavicle to their insertion on the first rib.
The thoracic outlet is far more difficult to visualise, being a three-dimensional structure. As the subclavian artery, becoming the axillary artery, and the brachial plexus emerge from the inter scalene triangle, they pass between the first rib and the clavicle on their way to the shoulder and thence to the whole arm and hand.
On the way, they pass under the tendon of the pectoralis muscle, which we will see can have significance.
NEUROLOGICAL / VASCULAR
The brachial plexus (C5-T1) may be irritated and occasionally physically compromised as it emerges from the Scalene Triangle, either by the first rib, or hypertrophy or spasm of the scalene muscles, or the clavicle, or by any structure that invades this space.
A cervical rib, very occasionally an apical lung tumour
(Pancoast, for example), or scar tissue from old injuries may invade the
interscalene space. Old fractures of the first rib, or the clavicle may
set up compression of the artery or nerves as scar tissue grows around
the fractured bone.
First rib fixation
Note that the subclavian artery passes through the interscalene triangle, but the vein, in blue, doesn't. There are grooves in the first rib to accomodate the artery and vein.
Normally, the first rib should descend on exhalation as the scalenes relax. However, either a first rib fixation, or scalene spasm may prevent the rib descending.
The first rib articulates posteriorally with a single facet with the body of T1 and anteriorally with the sternum via a costal cartilage allowing for limited movement of the rib in inspiration and expiration.
A (left, say) first rib fixation may be detected by rotating the
head to the SAME side with the right hand, palpating the body of the
left first rib (in its central part) and then gently depressing the rib
with the left fingers whilst simultaneously laterally flexing the neck
to the SAME side (to reduce upward scalene traction on the rib).
Normally, you can feel the rib depressing under the pressure of the fingers. When fixated it has a hard rigid feeling. The examiner shoulder then palpate along the length of the first rib to determine if the fixation is more at the costo-sternal, or costo-thoracic joints.
Occupations that involve lifting the arms for long periods, such electricians, hairdressing, playing a musical instrument such as the violin or clarinet, and carrying a backpack... close down the space between the clavicle and the first rib, and may compromise the thoracic outlet.
Typical vascular symptoms would include fatigue when using the arm. In effect an intermittent claudication. At rest there are minimal vascular symptoms, but on use of the arm, especially with the arms raised when the arterial system is even further compromised in the Thoracic Outlet, and ischemia soon occurs.
Further laterally, the neurovascular bundle passes between the Pec Minor tendon and the chest wall. In cases of hypertrophy and chronic tendonitis they may be compromised, again especially when the arm is elevated.
The axillary artery also passes beneath the Pec Minor tendon.
About 2 people per thousand have an extra cervical rib, located above
the normal first thoracic rib. This cervical rib penetrates through the
inter scalene triangle, taking up space and when large can produce
severe signs and symptoms in the arm.
SYMPTOMS of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
When the subclavian / axillary artery is affected primarily, the arm quickly tires, especially as stated previously with the arm elevated, and the head extended and laterally flexed to the opposite side (watching where the worker is drilling/ working). The arm may feel cold and may have pins and needles. The differential should include Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, but the paresthesias then are only in the Median nn. distribution.
The subclavian vein is rarely affected as it normally passes anterior to the Scalene Triangle. However, a normal variant can occur with the vein exiting the Thoracic cage via the Scalene Triangle, in which case the arm may swell. Thrombus formation must be ruled out. I've have personally only seen one case in thirty years.
When the brachial plexus is affected primarily, there is often a vague dull, diffuse ache in the shoulder, arm and hand. Symptoms are of an intermittent nature. A key indicator is involvement of all fingers, though the lowest nerve trunks, which pass directly over the first rib, are most often affected, or worst affected, so the C8-T1 dermatomes are affected predominantly. Paresthesias and numbness may occur with pain radiating down into fingers. Carrying heavy objects in the arm, such as a shopping basket and sleeping with the arm elevated above the head will aggravate the condition.
Conversely, a true brachial neuralgia with nerve root irritation or compromise is usually relieved by elevation of the arm.
Shoulder Abduction Relief sign...
Diagnosis of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome
Watson, et al (Manual Therapy 2009; 14: 586-595) point that the diagnosis is often one of exclusion, with Thoracic Outlet Syndrome being used as a "fallback diagnosis". In their opinion 98% of TOS cases are of the neurogenic type. Differentials should include:
Arm Pain Quick DASH questionaire
DASH: Disability - Arm - Shoulder - Hand
This questionaire quickly gives the clinician an inkling of how
severe the patient's compaint is, and which activities are likely to
increase the symptoms. It's useful for the patient to download the
questionaire, and fill it in before the first consultation.
Arm pain Quick DASH questionaire ...
Clearly examination should be comprehensive and include the cervical spine, shoulder, elbow, wrist and hand.
THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME
For me the diagnosis of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome is confirmed by a positive Adson's Test, but it remains a subjective, and difficult to perform manoeuvre.
I personally find that in a frank case of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome it is not necessary to extend the arm (that is controversial and not standard practice!), (since the pulse is often obliterated in healthy subjects when extending the arm, giving many false positives.)
And I add an extra proviso...
If the pulse is obliterated by rotation of the head and neck to the same side, extension of the head and neck, and deep inhalation, AND THE PULSE RETURNS UPON RETURNING THE HEAD TO THE NEUTRAL POSITION AND EXHALING, then I am reasonably sure of the diagnosis of TOS.
To summarise: I make a diagnosis of Thoracic Outlet Syndrome if at least three of the following are positive:
Other orthopaedic tests
The Hands-Up test
THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME
This rather brutal test comes in two forms:
A positive test: a deep numb ache in the arms (that I have myself after three minutes, in the extended position, and I definitely don't suffer from THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME!), pain or tingling in the fingers and arms, or an excessively tired arm.
My own opinion is that if the diagnosis is based on Hands-up test, particularly with the shoulders extended, then half the world will be found to be suffering from Thoracic Outlet Syndrome!
Costo-Clavicular manoeuvre for TOS
Placing one's fingers in the supraclavicular space it is easy to palpate the first rib approximating the clavicle as the abducted arm is flexed and extended.
In the CostoClavicular manoeuve, the doctor seeks a strong radial pulse, extends the arm and depresses the shoulder, waiting for a cessation of the pulse.
In a true positive, for my money, the radial pulse should return when the arm is returned to neutral.
UPPER LIMB TENSION TEST
The ULTT is normally used as a test for a nerve root impingement. However it is equally useful in THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME, though less profoundly positive, giving a tight feeling / ache in the forearm.
My own opinion...
When examining the patient with a stubborn tennis elbow, frozen shoulder or Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, I frequently find both a first rib fixation and a positive Adson's test. I believe it to be the adjustment of the first rib fixation that gives Chiropractic the edge in the management of these arm and shoulder conditions. Though there is no research confirming that Chiropractic can help CTS, it's not often that I fail in the management of this sometimes stubborn and nasty condition. Oh for the time to test this with some solid blinded research.
Frequently it takes only one or two adjustments of the first rib to free the fixation. But... a mid-low cervical fixation is often then found. At first I doubted my palpation skills, but it occurs so frequently that I believe it be part of the syndrome.
My opinion? The cervical facet fixation sets up the Scalene spasm that leads to the typical Thoracic Outlet signs and symptoms. The the question arises: Is the fixated rib primary to the condition, the spasm in the scalenes causing the first rib fixation? Is it cause or effect?
An important question.
Does the fixated first rib, and the development of THORACIC OUTLET SYNDROME set up the patient for a frozen shoulder for example. Or is the frozen shoulder the cause of the fixated rib and scalene spasm?
Chiropractic management of these neck-shoulder-arm pain syndromes
The correct protocol is to fix what you find. If there's a fixated rib, then adjust it. If there's a capsulitis, or radial head fixation, or active trigger points in the Pronator teres... fix it by whatever tools one has.
Then, mostly, the patient gets better. Mostly!
Many insurance companies now only pay for physical therapists to provide a chiropractic adjustment; that's in the face of powerful research proving that inclusion of DCs to perform their own technique would save them a good deal of money. One has to conclude that political medicine has gone off on another tack to contain our profession.
It's being successful with some doctors of chiropractic quitting. Others become involved in some dodgy practices, like demanding that patients sign up for a whole year of treatment in advance, in order to stay in business.
In recessionary times, the going is tough when the insurance won't pay.
Is the day approaching for a new Wilk versus the AMA and the insurance companies?
The chiropractic profession has tried hard to stay on the moral high ground; those who stoop to unscrupulous practices need to be exposed and disciplined if we are not to stoop to the low blows that medicine has often resorted to contain and eliminate us.
Chiropractic Books.com and its two sister sites Chiropractic Help.com and Bernard Preston.com bring you plenty of information about new books, care of the body, and healthy living tips from your own vegetable and fruit gardening, to flaxseed for omega 3 and much more.